Originally Posted by: " 
Sorry, gotta disagree with you on this one, Julie. (Shawn doubtless remembers me disagreeing with him on the earlier thread. :) )
On several overlapping grounds, among them:
1. Unreasonable search under 4th amendment.
2. Invasion of natural right of privacy.
3. Restriction of natural right to travel.
4. Patriot Act should have been held unconsitutional.
5. Fear doesn't stop terrorism, it encourages it.
6. TSA has regularly adopted procedures that don't work; we should believe them this time because...?
7. If you have to presume that the average traveller is a criminal, then you've already lost.
8. Threatening a civil lawsuit if you fail to go through the screening? On what grounds, pray tell?
First.. your unrestricted travel is your right, but flying on commercial transportation is not a right. Your ability to purchase a seat freely is a right.. but you are then governed by their policies and regulations.
Personally the US government shouldn't be charged with the security, however they decided that since there are hubs with multiple airlines flying out of each and the importance of air transportation to our economy, they stuck their noses into it.
But I fail to see air travel as a right.. hence #1 has little governing authority.. if you want to fly, you have to follow their guidelines.
2. I will agree, that forcing someone to a "Xray" scan is taking it too far. But they are allowing a passenger to opt out..
3. See #1.. they are not restricting your travel.. just the conditions for this type of travel.
4. Certain parts I will agree to..
5. Is the TSA fear tactic or a method to dissolve it?
6. I would love to see a list of failed policies to counter the fact that it hasn't been repeated 9/11 event. To be fair, we can't decisively say that the TSA has prevented one either.
7. If I walk into Best Buy.. I have to pass through their scanners to exit.. so should I be offended that I was treated the same as a shoplifter? The method is not the same, but the principle of the TSA procedures are the same.. a preventative measure.
Same as the last thread, list an alternative measure than the TSA.
8. Here I agree.. a civil lawsuit.. that is utter bullshit.